“Who should we give birth to, poverty?” Deputy demanded to have children from 18 years old and criticized payments – readers did not appreciate the proposal – September 9, 2024 Publication in CHAT: Russia Deputy calls for giving birth at 18. Source: Artem Ustyuzhanin / E1.RU Young people should start families while still students, at 18-19 years old, and have children as early as possible. Their grandparents should help them raise them. However, the idea of stimulating the birth rate with cash payments is not the best way for future parents to be confident in the future, says State Duma deputy Zhanna Ryabtseva: "I can say: give birth, give birth and give birth." give birth again, you will have to give birth. We need to form families in colleges, because the best families are those student families who then go through life together. The most important thing is that the girl or the young man already has a partner, so that it is not just some kind of hobby. They understand that they are going together. And then you can give birth at 18-19 years old, when you understand that next to you there is a person who will be with you all your life. Grandmothers and grandfathers should help, and this is essential. , because this education is the best," she says. After the article was published, readers of City Portals from different regions of the country left hundreds of comments. Their questions and thoughts were very diverse. We decided to share some of them here, grandmothers. Zhanna Ryabtseva suggests helping young parents with their education. If women give birth at 18, then not only the grandmother, but also the great-grandmother will not retire, and how can they help? The birth at 20, the daughter at 19. So? The grandmother is only 39. She goes to the moon until retirement. He clearly will not be able to sit with her grandson. Is it possible that the mother and daughter will give birth to a child every year and, consequently, there will be a lifetime maternity leave," a reader of 76.RU from Yaroslavl noted the problem. "At 18, the couple should already be "mature" for parenthood? That is, not study, not enjoy carefree youth, but give birth and save money for the grandmother? Grandma, excuse me, should I resign and stay with my grandson while the children study? My child is 18. I am 43. And I still have 17 years of work left before retirement. And my plans (both life and financial) do not include quitting and raising grandchildren,” a user of E1.RU from Yekaterinburg was surprised about the deputy’s statement. Young parents. Many were surprised by the call to give birth, even at 18-19 years old. Previously, this was the motto “Study, study and study.” Today, “Give birth, give birth and give birth again” – Students give birth not because of great intelligence, but because of its absence. There is a lack of responsibility, but then some, looking after children, realize this. Not all, of course, – says a reader of 72.RU from Tyumen. – What kind of families are students in now? They used to pay stipends, but now, for example, at the SSMU you have to pay 350 thousand rubles a year for treatment. After graduation, you will have to pay off your student loan for another 10 years. What children? “We would like to feed ourselves and pay off our debt to the state,” asks an NGS.RU observer from Novosibirsk. People are sure that at 18-19 years old, a family will not have enough money.RU — I was ready to start a family at 23, after graduating from university, but all the guys wanted to go out, and no one asked to get married. That's why I had my first child at only 26. Where can I find serious people during my student years? — asks an NGS.RU reader from Novosibirsk. “I don't understand anything.” Give birth to students, she says. But don't give them money, let them earn money. So what should we do? Study, give birth, or work? — asks a 72.RU commentator from Tyumen Where would we be without money. But even if you imagine that you can give birth, and your parents will help you, then the question of caring for a young family arises. remains After all, incentive payments for children, according to the deputy, are not the best idea. Yes, yes, give birth! Mortgage at 20%, studio apartment 3.5 million rubles, salary 25-40 thousand. Live and do not deny yourself anything! How I do not envy today's youth! - Considering the current sky-high prices for housing, a million for each child would probably be fairer. Without normal housing, it is very difficult to plan children, ”writes the E1.RU observer from Yekaterinburg. “Until there is housing, stable work, where to give birth? ”Who should give birth? At 18? Don't make me laugh. At 18, you need to study, look for a job with an income to pay off a mortgage for 20 years, and then before 40 you need to have a child, ”advises a user of CHITA.RU. in Chita “Who should I give birth to?” Is this poverty? My husband and I work, at 34 she went on maternity leave, so what? Living for 1.5 years on "child care" from an employer for 11 thousand? Very funny! People strive for something, work, a mortgage and bam, maternity leave, but who will want to give birth after that?! What is the pay? What support? What are you talking about? Who can live on a minimum wage?! - an NGS.RU reader from Novosibirsk is indignant, - No problem! Got married, had a child - free education and housing from the state! This will cause a population explosion in you! - recommends a 72.RU commentator from Tyumen. Insufficient age. And if you look at the whole picture, people from all over Russia are sure that people who are 18 are still too young to start a family, have children and have "adults". Are you serious? Are 18-year-olds approved for a mortgage and can they afford it? Where to give birth, in a tent? Or to parents in a mortgaged apartment – How will you understand at 18 that this is the person you want to spend your life with?! People really do change, – says a reader of NGS.RU from Novosibirsk, – graduated from school, gave birth, and so what? You don’t get an education, don’t study? And what kind of faith can there be in the future? We saw the prices: baby food, a stroller, a crib, etc., plus buy an apartment on a mortgage at a price, and sit happily, give birth and survive in landfills and in “I’ll give it away for free” groups carrying someone else’s things. Then you read articles: here’s a suicide, here he became an alcoholic, and his children were sent to an orphanage. Salaries should match prices! Then there will be such a birth rate when there will be no rich and poor! – says one of the commentators of 72.RU from Tyumen – Modern women cannot plan a family and give birth to children. Especially at the age of 18-20, when in their youth they fall in love with extreme psychos, flirts and jealous people, get pregnant from them, and then become embittered and raise their children with such an idea of the world that all men are scoundrels. , - says a reader of 72.RU from Tyumen - The most important thing is not a word about love! What is this anyway? Why don't you teach love, encourage people to fall in love, create families, and from love children are born happy! - at the end of the discussion writes a user of NGS.RU from Novosibirsk Yes, everything is written correctly, 18-year-old children will not be needed in the near future, and grandmothers will sit! , gave birth early and somehow it worked out, no need to raise an argument Source link Source link
